I have a few ideas for “On Flesh.” I’ll go in order of what, at this point, strikes me as most interesting to least.
1. Starting point: Body horror–why it works.
For those that aren’t familiar, body horror is a sometimes-sexualized form of fear inducement popularized in large part by the films of David Cronenberg (Videodrome, The Fly, and more recently A History of Violence and Eastern Promises). Typically, it involves a usually-inevitable, scarily-slow-but-far-too-fast destruction, mutilation, or mutation of the human body. (Films ranging from District 9 to Moon to Saw use such techniques. I, for one, find it extremely effective, and I think others do, too.
Is it because of the human element, the sense of empathy involved in another’s suffering? Is that what we tell ourselves to mask our own sadism? Or is it, as I suspect, that we vicariously experience another’s sufferings because our greatest fears our for ourselves and for our bodies? It’s a question that interests me a lot, and I have a possibly related, visceral fear of amputated anythings that’s just begging to be explored.
2. What does our approach to hospitals mean for our views on the body? Typically, they are characterized by sterility, fluorescence, and a sort of inhuman detachment from the suffering that goes on within and around them–the very things doctors, at least in America, are so often accused of. But does it go broader than that? Is there a lack of empathy in, either, our healthcare system or our hospitals? Are they effectively a way to bottle up sickness into a place so unpleasant we’d hate to tread there? Or are they simply designed to ward off whatever crude, schadenfreudian fascination we may have with dissection, cadavers, disease, and others’ suffering?
Essentially, hospitals are sterilized in many, many ways. I’m curious about what that sterility means and entails. I spent a lot of time in hospitals growing up (working parent) and it might be interesting to explore.
3. I’m interested in exploring the cost of things we prize such as safety and privacy. I think that’s really about protecting our bodies, in a way. That may overlap too much with No Man’s Land, though, and I don’t want to find myself imitating too much.
4. Why is meditation so rare here? Why is drug use (apart, mostly, from drinking) to achieve different states so frowned upon? In countless other cultures and many other places, such things are common. Simple, transcendental meditation can be accomplished without the tacit approval of the masses, as in church. There’s a form of individualized, personal expression and examination that goes on with it/them that I think is often underrated in our culture. Relatedly, why is there one specific “time for experimentation,” that being college? Does acquisition of new responsibility actually end that trial period for risktaking or is that just an excuse we tell ourselves? How does it factor in with general repression?
5. I’d be really interested in examining what people’s voices do for them. Aside from obvious instances like opera, I want to look at how voices work and what they do in people’s day-to-day lives. How consistently do they reflect people’s internal states? How are they weaponized? Are they often barriers to self-expression? To love or sex? Do they define us?
(Last one, I promise. A lot of these are coming to mind).
6. “Pleasures of the flesh:” Despite frequent claims that we are oversexed, the vestiges of puritanical culture seem to be alive and well in our culture. There’s an aversion and condemnation of numerous immediate pleasures and risktaking behaviors, which are treated, typically, with distance, timid fascination, or even revulsion. 127 Hours is a key example, as Franco’s character appears almost to be on another planet, an eerie martian landscape, separate from the rest of us.
Overall, we have a frequent immersion to what is immediately pleasurable, to cathartic behavior, and, ultimately, to many of the behaviors that seem unnatural to us. With my disturbing “I hate fun” complex and a frequent, irrational sense of guilt that I think is shared by many people, this is probably a topic that I, personally, most need to explore. That being said, I may need more space and more time to adequately do it.
Having what I might call an unusual voice, I’d say I have some stake in the matter.